
Penny Patricia Boudreau has been sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 20 years after pleading guilty to second-degree murder in the death of her 12-year-old daughter Karissa.
The 34-year-old former Shelburne County resident pled guilty to the lesser charge in Bridgewater Supreme Court on Friday. (Jan. 30), re-electing to be tried by judge alone, and proceeding directly to sentencing.
Sobs of sorrow filled the courtroom as the chilling details of the crime were revealed for the first time.
Reading an agreed statement of facts in the case, Crown prosecutor Paul Scovil told the court that it was through an undercover sting operation that police were able to obtain Boudreau’s confession that she had strangled Karissa and dumped her half clothed body on the frozen banks of the LaHave River on Jan. 27, 2008.
Karissa’s remains were discovered on Feb. 9, 2008 by a nine-year-old boy and his mother. Police began to suspect Boudreau in the murder of Karissa two days after the body was discovered, when neighbors overheard a ruckus in the apartment shared by Boudreau and Macumber.
“Macumber was saying over and over ‘Penn, how could you do this,’” said Scovil.
The undercover operation began on Feb. 14, 2008 when Boudreau and her then boyfriend Vernon Macumber were first arrested and questioned in connection with the murder.
While Boudreau and Macumber were in custody an undercover officer posing as a cellmate was able to establish a bond with Macumber.
Acting on the opportunity, the undercover officer met with Macumber several times after his release, offering him the opportunity for work with him for a crime syndicate.
“A wide scale undercover operation began utilizing a number of scenarios to gain the trust of Macumber,” sad Scovil.
When the Boudreau and Macumber moved to Halifax on April 1, 2008, so did the undercover operation. During a meeting on April 16 Macumber made comments to the undercover operator to the effect that he had nothing to do with the murder of Karissa, and that he suspected Penny had murdered her daughter. He also told the undercover officer that he was still living with her in order to keep her close so she would not implicate him in the homicide.
“On May 3, 2008, undercover operators were able to convince Macumber they required the services of a female to assist in the work they were performing,” said Scovil. A meeting was arranged between Boudreau and the undercover operators and she became “very active with the undercover operators and their work.”
As the three-month anniversary of the discovery of Karissa’s body approached, investigators noticed that Boudreau was troubled by media reports that named her place of employment and commented on the value of DNA evidence. Boudreau made the comment to an undercover operator that she wished “the police exhibit vault would burn down or blow up.”
On June 11, a meeting was arranged between Boudreau and an undercover operator whom she was led to believe had connections and could possibly make her problem go away, but in order for him to help her she had to tell him everything about what happened to her daughter and she did.
Boudreau told the undercover operator that she and Macumber were having issues, and that Macumber had gave her an ultimatum to pick either him or Karissa.
For several days she thought about it before taking the life of her daughter.
On Jan. 27, the day Karissa disappeared, Boudreau told the undercover operator that she and Karissa had drove around for several hours talking and that things had gotten out of hand and they were both angry. “Boudreau said she ‘did what she had to do,’” said Scovil.
With Karissa in the car, Boudreau drove to the Sobeys parking lot at around 5:30 p.m. to pick up some groceries. While still in the store and Karissa still alive in the car, Boudreau called Macumber and left a message saying that Karissa was not in the car when she came out.
Boudreau then returned to the car, put the groceries in the trunk, grabbing a piece of beige twine and putting it in her pocket.
“Karissa kept wanting to get out of the car so Boudreau waited until it was dark and drove to the William Hebb Road and told Karissa that if she wanted to get out then, to get out,” said Scovil. “Boudreau said she couldn’t let her go back and tell people what a horrible mom she was.”
Both mother and daughter got out of the car into the dark, snowy night. Boudreau went to grab her daughter but it was slippery so she tackled her backwards to the ground, pinning Karissa down with her knees on her chest. With her hands underneath her Karissa couldn’t move.
“”Mommy don’t,’ was the only thing Karissa said,” said Scovil.
Face to face with her daughter, Boudreau took the twine and strangled Karissa until she felt her life drain away.
Boudreau then dragged Karissa’s body back to the car, and drove back to Bridgewater to decide what to do next. She put the twine in a Tim Horton’s cup and threw it into a garbage can at Tim Hortons on High Street, while Karissa’s body was still in the car.
Boudreau then drove to the turn around spot on King Street, adjacent to the LaHave River where she parked the car, shut it and the lights out, and using her blue jeans as leverage, dragged Karissa’s body to the edge of the steep embankment.
Karissa’s pants, underwear and socks came off as Boudreau dragged the body, said Scovil, which Boudreau felt would make people think Karissa was sexually assaulted.
“Boudreau stated Karissa’s hoodie and vest came off and she was left wearing a t-shirt with one pant leg in her jeans,” said Scovil. “Boudreau then rolled her over the edge of the bank knowing that the weather was calling for lots of snow” and Karissa’s body wouldn’t be found for a while.
Boudreau then got back in her car, taking the vest, hoodie and a croc, and throwing the articles of clothing into a garbage can by the Bridgewater swimming pool, realizing the other piece of footwear was missing..
Boudreau then went home and told Macumber that Karissa was missing, calling the police, as well as family, friends and teachers to check and see if anyone knew where Karissa was.
Scovil said Boudreau told the undercover operator that she would do anything for Macumber and the thought of losing him was harder than the thought of losing her daughter.
“A mother killing her child is an inconceivable act,” said Scovil. “Karissa was failed by the one person who should have protected her, her mother.”
Before passing sentence victim impact statements from Karissa’s father Paul Boudreau, and stepmother Chasity Grear were read to the court.
In his statement, Karissa’s father said that he had many dreams of being many things in his daughter’s life but “now all those dreams are gone… the centre of those dreams is gone because of one selfish act.”
Grear wrote that there are no words to describe what the family has endured over the past year. “We struggle through each day and ask not why but what good can come out of this senseless act of violence… Karissa got a death sentence. We got a life sentence.”
In passing down sentence, Justice Margaret Stewart said this was a “violent death” that not only shocked the community but the police as well, noting the circumstances in the case are close to first degree murder.
Justice Stewart noted that Boudreau didn’t turn herself in, didn’t show remorse to the undercover operator, and mused that it must have been “crocodile tears” that Boudreau shed when she so passionately made the public appeal for the safe return of Karissa.
“You can never call yourself mother again in connection with Karissa,” Justice Stewart told Boudreau. “Mommy don’t are words that will haunt you for the rest of your life.”
When asked if she had anything to say, Boudreau offered a tearful “I’m sorry.”
Justice Stewart accepted the joint recommendation from crown and defense for life in prison, with eligibility for parole after 20 years, or June 14, 2028. Boudreau’s sentence starts from the date of her arrest.
Under what is known as the faint hope clause, Boudreau can apply for parole after 15 years.



